Guest post by: Colleen Orlando | 6th Grade ELA Teacher and 8th Grade Class Advisor, Secaucus Middle School | Secaucus, NJ | @colleeno711
Teaching comes with a lot of writing that isn’t teaching. Feedback comments. Reading guides. Notes home. None of it is optional, and all of it competes with the part of the job I love, which is being in the room with my kids.
So I started handing the first draft of some of that work to AI. Not the decisions. Just the first draft. I have one hard rule: the bot drafts, I decide. Nothing reaches a student without my eyes on it first.
I also want to say this plainly up front. AI isn’t perfect yet. It gets things wrong, and it can sound very sure of itself while it does. That’s exactly why the rule exists.
A small team, one job each
Instead of one AI tool that does everything, I set up a few assistants, each with a single job. A narrow task keeps me clear on what I’m asking for and what I need to check.
- Red Pen Pal drafts feedback comments on student writing. Reading Buddy 8/9 does the same job for my periods 8/9 C-level inclusion class. I read the drafts, fix what needs fixing, and copy them into Google Classroom myself.
- Page Turner helps me with lesson plans and reading guides.
- Photo Bouncer checks classroom photos before I post anything, so a student who can’t be posted doesn’t end up in a picture by accident.
- Draft Diva drafts parent emails and other school communications.
A couple of them work outside of school too. Dinner Diva plans my weekly dinners, and Posty Pink drafts my posts on X. Same rule for all of them.
What “I decide” actually looks like
Here’s the honest part about the workload. I don’t rewrite every draft. If I did, there would be no point. Most drafts are close. Some need a word or a sentence changed. A few go back to the drawing board.
The job isn’t to redo the bot’s work. The job is to catch the ones that aren’t right yet. So most of my time goes into reading, not rewriting.
Here’s a real one from a Do Now (the name is changed):
The draft: “Leo, good start. Explain more and write at least 5 sentences.”
What went to Leo: “Leo, good start. Next time, explain your ideas more and write at least 5 sentences.”
A small change, but it matters. The Do Now was done, and I didn’t want kids going back to redo it. I wanted Leo to know what to do next time. The bot couldn’t know that. I could.
The checks I run on every draft
My list is short on purpose, because I run it for every student, including the last paper of the night.
- Does it sound like me? My students know how I talk. If I wouldn’t say it out loud to that kid at their desk, it doesn’t go out.
- Is it accurate to their actual work? I check the comment against what the student wrote, not what a typical 6th grader might have written.
- Is it kind and specific? Kind doesn’t mean soft. A comment can push a kid and still make it clear I’m on their side.
- Would I be comfortable if a parent read it?
- Could this comment go on any other kid’s paper? This is my favorite check. If I could copy it onto the next student’s paper and it still made sense, it isn’t done yet.
That last one does the most work. Sixth graders can spot a fake compliment from across the room. Feedback only works if the kid believes it was written for them.
Protecting student privacy
Privacy is the next thing I want to tighten up. Next year, I plan to give each student a number at the start of the year and work off those numbers, so my assistants never see student names. I’ll add the names back myself when I copy comments into Google Classroom. It’s one more small step, and I think it’s worth it.
If you want to try this
You don’t need a whole team to start. Here’s what I’d suggest:
- Pick one duty that eats your time. Start there and nowhere else.
- Give the assistant one job.
- Write your own short list of checks, and run it every single time.
- Never let it send anything on its own. You copy, paste, and send. That step is where you stay in charge.
AI can give me a head start on the writing that surrounds teaching. It can’t know my students. That part stays with me, and that’s the point. The bot drafts. I decide.
Teachers, what’s the one check you never skip before something AI-drafted reaches a student?
For more on my checking process, see my X article, How I Check Every AI Draft Before Kids See It.
About Colleen
Colleen Orlando teaches 6th grade ELA at Secaucus Middle School in Secaucus, New Jersey, and serves as the 8th grade class advisor. She also runs the TPT store Orlando’s English Emporium. Find her on X at @colleeno711, where she shares what’s working (and what isn’t) with AI in her classroom.
About Rachelle
Dr. Rachelle Dené Poth is a Spanish and STEAM: What’s Next in Emerging Technology Teacher. Dr. Rachelle Dené Poth is an edtech consultant, presenter, attorney, author, and teacher of Spanish and STEAM: Emerging Technology. Rachelle has a Juris Doctor degree from Duquesne University School of Law and a Doctorate in Instructional Technology. Rachelle’s focus was on the need for professional development for educators, specific to Artificial Intelligence. Rachelle specializes in Artificial Intelligence, AI and the Law, AI and Healthcare, Cybersecurity, and STEM. She has more than 8 years of experience teaching and presenting on AI in her classroom, as well as working with educators worldwide.
Rachelle recently served as the Grant Coach for an initiative through ISTE+ASCD and Pinterest. Rachelle worked with a Task Force from 12 districts in the United States and assisted with policy revision, professional development, and the design of digital wellness resources for students, educators, and families.
Rachelle provides professional development related to AI policy and implementation to school districts, universities, and organizations. She also presents and provides keynotes on AI at state, national, and international events and in schools. Rachelle also provides AI training for other industries, including business, healthcare, and legal fields.
Rachelle is an ISTE-certified educator and recipient of the ISTE Making IT Happen Award and several Presidential Awards for volunteer service to education. Rachelle received the EdTech Trendsetter Award from EdTech Digest in 2024 and 2026.
She is the author of ten books, including “What the Tech? An Educator’s Guide to AI, AR/VR, the Metaverse and More! and “How to Teach AI: Weaving Strategies and Activities Into Any Content Area.” She has written curricula and courses on AI for all levels.
She is also a blogger for Defined Learning, EdTech K12, Edutopia, Getting Smart, and Tech & Learning. She is the host of the ThriveinEDU podcast, ISTE’s Learning Unleashed podcast, and The Lift by Amazon on BAM Radio Network. Contact Rachelle for your event! Check out her website: https://rachelledenepoth.com/

