What Students Need Now, Part I: Students Need Clarity, Not Conflicting Rules

Over the past few years, I have spoken with educators, school and district leaders, students, and families about artificial intelligence. Through professional learning, student conversations, task forces, classroom visits, and work with schools across the country, I have identified some similar questions and areas of concern.

  • What are students allowed to do with AI?
  • When is using AI considered cheating?
  • Do students need to tell a teacher when they use AI?
  • Can students use it to brainstorm but not write?
  • Can they use it for one class but not another?
  • What happens when different teachers have different expectations?

While speaking with students, these are questions that were frequently asked. These questions are important, and they reveal something we need to address. Clarity.

As schools continue to develop policies, guidance, and expectations around artificial intelligence, we cannot assume that simply having a policy means students understand what is expected of them.

In fact, one of the challenges I continue to see is the difference between what a school believes it has communicated and what students actually understand.

That gap matters. And we need to be proactive when deciding how to close that gap.

Students Are Navigating Different Expectations

Think about what a student’s day might look like.

In one class, a teacher may encourage students to use generative AI to brainstorm ideas.

In another, students may be allowed to use AI only after they have completed their own initial work.

A third teacher may not permit AI at all.

Another may allow it but require students to cite or disclose exactly how it was used.

Each of those decisions may be completely appropriate based on the learning goals of the class or assignment.

Each of these scenarios is something that I have heard in my work with schools and educators over the past year. And it is something that I’ve heard from students because they see the differences when their classmates are in a classroom where the use of AI is acceptable and they are being taught about it, and they themselves are in a classroom where they are not permitted to use AI. They have always expressed what an impact this has on their learning because they feel that they are not as prepared as their classmates when it comes to the following year, and there is an expectation that they understand how to use AI and other technologies.

But the problem is not necessarily that expectations differ.

The problem comes when students do not understand why they differ or what the expectations actually are. They want to be part of the conversation and decision-making.

If we want students to make responsible decisions about AI, they need more than a list of prohibited tools or a paragraph buried in an acceptable use policy. We can accomplish this if we listen and understand what it is that they want.  Some areas that we can focus on and understand are when it comes to our students:

  • They need context.
  • They need conversations.
  • They need examples.
  • And they need opportunities to ask questions before they make a mistake.

This is especially important because AI use is not always as simple as “used AI” or “did not use AI.”

A student might ask AI to suggest possible research topics, while another might use it to explain a difficult concept.

Someone might ask for feedback on something they already wrote, while a student might use translation support.

Sometimes students may use AI to generate an entire response and submit it without taking the time to review or understand it.

Each of these represents very different uses of AI.

If we treat each of them the same, we will not help students develop the judgment they will need to be successful.

Students Need to Understand the Why

Something I think we need to improve in our work is to explain the reasoning behind our expectations. If a teacher asks students not to use AI for an assignment, students should understand why. I always explain the reason behind the tools that I choose to use or the decisions that I make about our classroom practices.  There are different reasons for this:

  • Maybe the teacher needs to see what students can do independently.
  • Perhaps the goal of the assignment is to practice a specific skill.
  • Maybe students are working through productive struggle, and turning immediately to AI would remove an important part of the learning process.

There may also be times when AI is encouraged because the learning goal is different.

  • Students might compare AI-generated information with trusted sources.
  • They might critique an AI response.
  • They could use AI to generate possibilities and then evaluate them.
  • They might explore how changing a prompt changes an output.
  • Or they might use AI as part of a design process while documenting the decisions they make along the way.

When students understand the purpose behind the expectation, the conversation changes. Instead of their teachers telling them, “You can’t use AI,” they begin to understand, “For this task, I need to show what I can do independently,” or “For this task, AI can support part of my process, but I am still responsible for the thinking and final decisions.”

When they engage in these activities, it becomes a much more useful skill to develop.

Clarity Does Not Mean One Rule for Everything

Sometimes, when we talk about consistency, people assume that it means every teacher must have exactly the same rule for AI. I don’t think that is realistic, and I am not sure it would be helpful. And after speaking with students across the country last year, I don’t think that this would work very well. They want transparency, clarity, and consistency, but they want to be involved in the process.

The role AI can play in a Spanish class may look different from its role in science, mathematics, art, computer science, or English.

The expectations may also change based on students’ ages, the purpose of the assignment, or the skills being assessed.

Consistency should not necessarily mean identical rules. It should mean that students know how to determine what is expected.

A school might establish a common language around different levels of AI use.

For example:

  • AI is not permitted for this task.
  • AI may be used for specific parts of the process.
  • AI may be used with disclosure.
  • AI is intentionally incorporated into the assignment.

The exact categories can vary. What matters is that students do not have to guess. If expectations change from assignment to assignment, make sure you let the students know.

If disclosure is required, show students what meaningful disclosure looks like. We have to model appropriate use for them.

If certain types of AI assistance are acceptable and others are not, provide examples that will resonate with them and help them develop their skills.

We cannot expect students to navigate an increasingly complicated technology environment responsibly if the adults  (educators) around them have not clearly explained the boundaries. Modeling, guiding, and ongoing support are essential.

Students Should Be Part of the Conversation

One of the biggest takeaways I have from the year of work that I did with the 12 different districts is that students need to be involved. Student voice matters so much in AI planning. Adults may think an expectation is perfectly clear until we ask students to explain it back to us. We need to ask them:

  • What do students think AI use means?
  • What do they believe their teachers expect?
  • Where are they confused?
  • Which tools are they actually using?
  • What situations make it difficult for them to know what is appropriate?
  • What do they wish adults understood about how students are using AI?

These questions that lead to conversations will reveal gaps that policies alone will never identify. Students I have spoken with have called out inconsistencies in AI implementation, and in many other cases, students may notice inconsistencies that educators and leaders do not see because students move from classroom to classroom throughout the day.

They experience the system differently, and that perspective is valuable. Including students in conversations about AI does not mean students should decide every policy or expectation.

If a policy is intended to guide student behavior, educators must understand how students interpret it.

Move From Catching Students to Teaching Students

Another reason clarity matters is that too much of the early conversation about generative AI focused on catching students using it. We talked about academic integrity, and the focus areas included:

  • Detection.
  • Cheating.
  • Prohibition.
  • Consequences.

And it is true. Academic integrity absolutely matters. But if our primary strategy is trying to catch misuse after it happens, we are missing an important educational opportunity. Rather than focusing on “catching” a student using AI, we should be teaching students how to make better decisions before misuse occurs, and that requires more than telling them what not to do. Students need to know how to ask themselves:

  • What is the purpose of this assignment?
  • Am I supposed to demonstrate my own understanding?
  • Would using AI remove the thinking I am supposed to be doing?
  • Is AI permitted for this part of the work?
  • Do I need to disclose how I used it?
  • Did I verify what it produced?
  • Can I explain the final work without relying on the tool?
  • Am I still responsible for what I submit?

These questions build judgment. And judgment is far more useful than simply knowing how to avoid getting caught.

Clarity Protects Trust

When expectations are unclear, students may feel as though the rules are constantly changing. I have heard this from groups of students that I have spoken with. And teachers may become frustrated because students are using AI in ways that are not appropriate or helpful for their learning. Outside of school, families may not know what schools expect, and administrators may discover that policies are being interpreted differently across classrooms.

With all of the different roles and stakeholders in the school community, the lack of knowledge leads to uncertainty, which can erode trust. To avoid this, we need to prioritize clear communication because it does the opposite.

Students are more likely to make responsible decisions when they understand the boundaries.

Teachers are more likely to feel supported when there is shared language and guidance.

Families are better positioned to reinforce expectations when they know what those expectations are.

And schools can move beyond reacting to individual incidents and toward developing a more thoughtful culture around AI use.

What Students Need Now

Students are growing up in a time when the technology available to them is changing faster than many policies, curricula, and institutional systems can keep pace.

They are going to make mistakes, and so will educators and leaders, and this is something we should expect.

But uncertainty about emerging technology does not mean we should leave students to figure everything out on their own. They need adults who are willing to explain expectations, acknowledge when the answers are still developing, and provide guidance that evolves as the technology changes.

Students also need to understand that responsible AI use is not simply about following rules. It is about learning how to make decisions, and that means knowing when AI can support learning and when it may interfere with it. Beyond that, it means:

  • Understanding when independent thinking matters.
  • Recognizing when information needs to be verified.
  • Knowing what information should never be shared.
  • Accepting responsibility for the work and decisions that remain theirs, even when AI is involved.

We cannot prepare students for an AI-shaped world by giving them a constantly changing list of things they are allowed or not allowed to do.

We have to help them understand why those decisions matter. Students need:

  • clear expectations.
  • consistency where consistency makes sense.
  • explanations when expectations differ.
  • opportunities to ask questions.
  • a voice in conversations about technology that increasingly shapes their learning and their lives.

Before we can expect students to use AI responsibly, ethically, and intentionally, we have to make sure they understand what responsible, ethical, and intentional use actually looks like.

That clarity is something students need now.


Check out my new website: https://rachelledenepoth.com/

I would love it if you would subscribe to my ThriveinEDU newsletter and follow my podcast and YouTube channel to check out some interviews and other learning opportunities.

If Your Organization Is Beginning This Work

I help schools and other organizations (law firms, healthcare professionals, business owners) implement AI responsibly through policy guidance, professional learning, and classroom-ready strategies grounded in both instructional practice and legal insight.

My sessions focus on helping teams:

• understand what AI can and cannot do

• recognize responsible-use considerations

• build confidence using emerging tools

• align implementation with organizational priorities

If your school, district, or organization is beginning conversations or looking to dive in and learn more about AI policy, professional learning, or responsible implementation, I’d welcome the opportunity to support your next steps through leadership workshops, keynote sessions, or strategic planning partnerships.

Preparing people is what makes AI implementation successful. Contact me via bit.ly/thriveineduPD or email Rdene915@gmail.com for my training and speaking services.

Article content

Leave a Reply